02/11/08 Tip of the Week: Project Portfolio Management: Tip 4 - Use a proven PPM tool.
February 11, 2008 @ Project Management Tips of the Week from Mark Perry
This article is syndicated from Project Management Tips of the Week
. The original article is available here. Read more in PMO Tips, Project Management News .
No tag for this post.
Popularity: 1%
Reminder : PMToolbox has ZERO tolerance to copyright violation and agrees to follow strictly PMI's Professional Responsibility. That's why each post on this site includes a link to the original version at its source site.
Comments
One Response to “02/11/08 Tip of the Week: Project Portfolio Management: Tip 4 - Use a proven PPM tool.”
Got something to say?
[?]
Type in a relevant tag, and click the button, and help organize this blog's information.
[More Help]
[More Help]
Earned Value
IT governance
metadata
Project Office
Tools
Crm Applications
Project and Program Management
Microsoft Project
portfolio management
Methodologies
Hosted
Estimating
Program Management Office
EVM
best practices
sharepoint
Articles
application portfolio management
Application Development Methodology
Cost Benefit Analysis
Business Intelligence Tools
Deliverable Templates
IT Service Management
Knowledge Management Processes
Systems Development
Package Selection
SPI
Prince2
Information Technology Planning
PMO
Education and Training
Construction
Project Management
enterprise architecture
Resources
Risk Management Programs
Software
Information Engineering
EV
ITIL
associations
templates
CPI
Industry-Specific
MS Project

This posting is so off the mark I’m not sure where to begin. The only statement that is accurate at all is the first one - “PPM involves tradeoffs of value, cost, resources, and risk.” The rest of it is nice in theory but just misguided.
There is no tool that can “optimize a portfolio in a seamless manner.” Unless I’ve missed something and artificial intellgence has emerged. A tool simply lets you get to data and that is where humans who understand investment valuation and evaluation have to be involved to help inform the resource allocation decisions and prioritize, fund and kill projects based on a thoughtful considerations of costs, financial and strategic benefits as well as risk.
I led and built the corporate portfolio management discipline at American Express, and we got by with excel and a simple plug-in to a SQL dbase. And we had deployed portfolio management globally and across marketing, IT, R&D, sales, operations, advertising, etc. We had nearly 4-6000 investments which we evaluated quarterly. Yes, the database was useful in letting us collect the info but it was crude. The analysis was done by individuals who understood the tenets of portfolio management. And the portfolio decisions made required a focus on organizational behavior and culture.
A fancy software with nice looking charts and other bells & whistles sounds interesting but is wholly unnecessary. Focus on the process & behavior. Once those are understood, you can consider whether a tool maybe an enabler of the discipline you’ve created. Don’t lead with the tool. After all, “A fool with a tool is still a fool.”
PPM vendors for the most part show little understanding of the process and behavioral elements and instead aim to sell their portfolio management ’solutions’ as elixirs.